Here's a good trick to supplement your black bachelorette party supplies: Anything chocolate looks "black," so if you're looking for black bachelorette party supplies like penis candy, just search for chocolate penis candy. Here are some I found:

Bite Sized Black Chocolate Penises - $5.79 (12 pieces)


Chocolate Penis Candy Party Pack - $10.99 (approx. 35 pieces)


Giant Chocolate Penis - $10.99 (4" Tall)


Black Chocolate Penis After Dinner Mints - $8.99 (10 pieces)